← Wednesday, November 18 deck

77Culture2 sources posting

WIRED: Philosopher Thomas Nagel, New Winner of the Berggruen Prize, Shares His Thoughts on AI

Thomas Nagel has done landmark work on consciousness in nonhumans; this week, he won the million-dollar Berggruen Prize for his contributions to the field. And he has a lot of thoughts on AI.

Context

Why it matters

One of the best known philosophers of consciousness weighing in on AI gives readers a serious voice in the debate over whether chatbots could ever be conscious.

WIRED posted that Thomas Nagel, known for landmark work on consciousness in nonhumans, won the million dollar Berggruen Prize this week for his contributions to the field, and that he has a lot of thoughts on AI. The post links to WIRED's piece. A widely shared reaction from Sam Buntz described the piece as Nagel explaining why AI can't be conscious.

Deep dive

WIRED posted that Thomas Nagel has done landmark work on consciousness in nonhumans, that this week he won the million dollar Berggruen Prize for his contributions to the field, and that he has a lot of thoughts on AI. The post links to WIRED's piece with him.

Nagel is best known for asking what it is like to be another kind of creature, which is why his view on AI matters to the current debate over machine consciousness. The WIRED post itself does not summarize his position. A widely shared reaction from Sam Buntz described the piece as Nagel on why AI can't be conscious, and welcomed one of the greatest philosophers of mind weighing in. That summary is Buntz's reading, not a direct quote from Nagel in this file.

X's news feed grouped the coverage under a story saying Nagel, at 89, marveled at chatbots' lifelike language but drew a line at the idea that producing language alone can make a machine conscious. Because that is a feed summary rather than a direct source, readers should check the WIRED piece for his exact words.

This is an interview and opinion item, ranked near the bottom of the deck. It is included because it was widely discussed and because the question of AI consciousness comes up often as labs publish model welfare and safety work.

What to expect next

Readers can check the full WIRED piece for Nagel's exact arguments. Expect responses from researchers who take the possibility of AI consciousness more seriously, including those working on model welfare at AI labs. The Berggruen Prize may bring more interviews where he expands on the topic. Any formal essay from Nagel on AI would be worth adding here, along with any lab response.