Toby Rogers, Citing the NYT: How Blackwell Chips Allegedly Reached China Through Megaspeed's Southeast Asian Data Centers
The NY Times has the receipts today. Here's how the Nvidia Blackwell chip laundering worked. 1. Nvidia was blocked from selling Blackwell chips to China. So Jensen Huang sold them to Alice Huang at Megaspeed which installed them in data centers in Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia. 2. Howard Lutnick's family and company (Cantor Fitzgerald) were also heavily invested in these southeast Asian data centers and Lutnick blocked regulatory enforcement against Nvidia. 3. The data centers then either sold compute to China or hollowed out the servers and shipped the Blackwell chips directly to China. (Reports of hollowed out servers are from others on X, not in the articles.) 4. Nvidia could claim correctly that they had not shipped Blackwell chips to China. But the Megaspeed middlewoman (Alice Huang) was clearly facilitating Chinese access. 5. The Trump administration has known this for a year. Jensen Huang and President Trump were eager to sell Blackwells to China so they opposed the restrictions and didn't seem to mind the circumventions of the embargo. Secretary Rubio seems to be the main character within the administration trying to enforce the law. It is also true that no one can run Nvidia other than Jensen Huang. So we are left in the unfortunate position where the CEO of the most important tech company in the world messed up and now the stock is going to crater and lots of people won't be able to retire because their stock portfolio just got nuked.
Context
The thread pulls the Nvidia scandal into one widely shared account, but it mixes New York Times reporting with unsourced claims from X, so readers should separate the two.
Nvidia has been barred from selling its Blackwell chips to China. Reporting this week has focused on Alice Huang and the company Megaspeed, which runs data centers in Southeast Asia. Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia CEO amid the scrutiny.
Deep dive
Toby Rogers posted a five point summary of what he said the New York Times reported on Nov 16 about how Nvidia Blackwell chips reached China despite the ban.
According to his thread, Jensen Huang sold the chips to Alice Huang at Megaspeed, which installed them in data centers in Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia. He wrote that the family and company of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Cantor Fitzgerald, were heavily invested in those data centers and that Lutnick blocked regulatory enforcement against Nvidia. He said the data centers then either sold compute to China or hollowed out servers and shipped the chips there, but he noted himself that the reports of hollowed out servers come from other X users, not from the articles.
He added that Nvidia could correctly say it had not shipped Blackwell chips to China, that the Trump administration had known about this for a year, and that Secretary Rubio appeared to be the official trying to enforce the law. The thread ends with his own opinion that no one else can run Nvidia and that the stock could fall sharply.
These are Rogers's characterizations. The underlying articles were not reviewed here, and Nvidia, Megaspeed, Lutnick and the White House have not confirmed the claims in the thread.
What to expect next
Watch for the full New York Times reporting to be quoted directly, and for responses from Nvidia, Megaspeed, Cantor Fitzgerald and the Commerce Department. Congressional hearings on Dec 1 and Dec 2, where Jensen Huang and Nvidia's general counsel are due to testify, may address whether chips were diverted. Any enforcement action against the data centers named in the thread would be the clearest confirmation.
