← Monday, November 16 deck

12Policy

SemiAnalysis Argues 1.5 GW of Chips Are in China Against US Law

More than 1.5 GW of chips are in China that shouldn’t be. Unwinding that web could reshape open-source AI. “In our view, there’s more than one and a half gigawatts of chips in China that are not supposed to be there according to US law. How they get there, that whole web, that’s what’s going to unwind.” “If NVIDIA can no longer support the open-source ecosystem, because that was Jensen’s primary goal, does that mean the open-source ecosystem falls away?” “Now open source looks a lot weaker with NVIDIA down and out. Anthropic looks much more likely to get a complete monopoly or a duopoly. This bodes really well for Anthropic’s IPO next week.” “They’re more diverse in what chips they use than any other company in the world.”

Opening frame from a SemiAnalysis video on chips in China.

Context

Why it matters

If the firm's own count is right, a very large stock of advanced chips is already in China, and it says unwinding that web could weaken open source AI.

SemiAnalysis posted that, in its view, more than 1.5 GW of chips are in China that are not supposed to be there according to US law, and that unwinding that web could reshape open source AI. The post is the firm's own analysis and argument, not a government finding. It also offers comments about Nvidia, the open source ecosystem, and Anthropic that should be read as SemiAnalysis's views.

Deep dive

SemiAnalysis, a chip industry research firm, said more than 1.5 GW of chips are in China that should not be there. In a quoted passage, it put the same point in its own voice: in our view, there is more than one and a half gigawatts of chips in China that are not supposed to be there according to US law, and how they get there, that whole web, is what will unwind. The 1.5 GW figure and the claim that this stock violates US law are SemiAnalysis's argument, not an official count from the Commerce Department or another US agency.

The same post then draws a longer chain of conclusions. It asks whether the open source ecosystem falls away if Nvidia can no longer support it, says open source looks weaker with Nvidia down and out, and says this bodes really well for Anthropic's IPO next week because Anthropic looks more likely to get a monopoly or a duopoly. It also says they, in context Anthropic, are more diverse in what chips they use than any other company in the world. Those lines are commentary from SemiAnalysis, including a remark about an Anthropic public listing that this file does not independently confirm.

The useful core is the 1.5 GW estimate and the claim of a web of chips in China that US law, in the firm's view, does not allow. The wider points about open source weakening and about Anthropic are speculative extensions of that view and should not be reported as settled facts.

This is first hand in the narrow sense that SemiAnalysis is stating its own analysis. It is not first hand official confirmation of the chip stock or of any enforcement action.

What to expect next

A government report, an export control action, or a detailed SemiAnalysis note with a method for the 1.5 GW figure would be the next hard evidence. Watch whether Commerce, customs cases, or other researchers corroborate a stock of that size. Comments in the same post about Nvidia, open source, and an Anthropic listing should be checked against primary sources before they are treated as events. If SemiAnalysis revises the number, this story should follow the revision.