← Sunday, November 15 deck

20Opinion1 source posting

Unverified: Tim Sweeney Says the Huang Reports Backtracked and Appear to Trace Back to a Single Rival Big Tech Lobbyist

The articles backtracked from their original incendiary, and now clearly false, claims to something more like "Jensen did lawful things that powerful people didn't like". It still appears the original claims came from a single competing Big Tech lobbyist. The reporting successfully disrupted corporate governance processes, with a running cost of $1.8 trillion in losses to American pension funds and shareholders. Here's what I fear is being lost in these articles: The proper interface between government and private citizens and their corporations is rule of law. Laws are passed, and if wrongdoing as alleged, then there's due process: an investigation followed by facts and evidence presented in open court. Due process should happen here: let the facts come out whole, and not as a trickle of dubious claims. Press takedowns full of sketchily sourced claims and backtracking narratives are not the way. It's what we see outside of the free world, and is no model for The United States of America. In particular, if the Jensen takedown succeeds on the basis of these journalistic failings, which is not by any means certain as Sam Altman's case shows, then it foreshadows an economically and institutionally ruinous new playbook to be adopted with no end in sight. Imagine a weekly stream of takedowns emerging from opportunistic alignments between corporate lobbyists and political interests which, given the new partisan split between the executive and legislative branches, will attack in all directions, undermining not only the US economy but American leadership in the world. I hope cooler heads prevail this coming week as they did not on Thursday November 12. And I urge anyone who happened to oppose Jensen, open models, and the underlying trade policies in question, to recognize that this isn't a win for "team regulation". It's a change in the game from a transparent rules-based one to a sinister new form centered around politicans and lobbyists.

Context

Why it matters

A prominent CEO is accusing the press and an unnamed competitor of driving Huang's ouster, a claim with no public evidence that is feeding the campaign to bring him back.

Epic Games CEO Tim Sweeney posted the long reply on November 15. He has been named among supporters of the petition to reinstate Huang. Huang resigned on November 12 after admitting an affair with Alice Huang, whom US officials suspect of working for Chinese intelligence, and the Justice Department has not reached a conclusion on whether she was a spy.

Deep dive

In the post, Sweeney writes that the articles backtracked from their original incendiary claims, which he calls now clearly false, to something more like Jensen doing lawful things that powerful people did not like. He says it still appears the original claims came from a single competing Big Tech lobbyist. He does not name the lobbyist or the company, and he offers no evidence for the claim.

Sweeney argues that the reporting disrupted corporate governance at a running cost of $1.8 trillion in losses to American pension funds and shareholders. He says the proper interface between government and citizens is the rule of law, with investigations and evidence presented in open court, not what he calls a trickle of dubious claims. He warns that if the takedown succeeds, it could set a playbook for regular takedowns driven by alliances between corporate lobbyists and political interests, and he urges opponents of Huang, open models and current trade policy not to treat it as a win for regulation.

The outlets involved, including CNN, The Washington Post, The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal, have continued to report on US officials' concerns about Alice Huang, and Nvidia's board has hired an independent law firm to investigate. Sweeney's reading of the coverage is his opinion, and his lobbyist claim is unverified.

What to expect next

Watch whether Sweeney or anyone else names the alleged lobbyist or produces evidence, and whether any outlet issues corrections. President Trump said on November 16 that he does not know that Alice Huang was a spy and would not mind Huang returning, which gives Sweeney's side political cover. Nvidia's board investigation and its quarterly report on November 17 are the next official checkpoints.