← Sunday, November 15 deck

19Opinion1 source posting

SemiAnalysis Lays Out the Devil's Advocate Case for Letting China Rent American Compute

The devil’s advocate case for letting China rent American compute. “If China has access to compute outside of China, it’s paying humongous margin dollars to the US ecosystem. Nvidia makes about $7 million of profit on every megawatt deployed. The cloud provider makes another $7 to 10 million at today’s pricing.” “If ByteDance wants to compete with Meta on video recommendation globally, and you don’t let it buy the chips but you do let it rent them, Meta potentially has a fourth of the cost of compute.” “Application-layer companies running on open models add up to well north of $10 billion in ARR. DeepSeek makes less than Baseten and Fireworks do serving its models. America is making so much money off Chinese models.”

A man in a dark shirt rests his chin on his hand in a video frame, beside an on screen card about the Remote Access Security Act on a dark background with a SemiAnalysis logo.

Context

Why it matters

As Washington moves to close the remote access loophole, one of the most followed chip research firms is airing the commercial case on the other side, which shows what US companies stand to lose.

SemiAnalysis posted the video clip on the evening of November 15, a day before the Commerce Department issued its rule restricting remote access to advanced chips. An on screen card in the clip refers to the Remote Access Security Act, a bill in Congress aimed at the same practice. The post presents the argument as a devil's advocate case, not as a settled position.

Deep dive

The clip quotes a speaker arguing that if China uses compute outside China, it pays very large margins to the US ecosystem. Per the quoted remarks, Nvidia makes about $7 million of profit on every megawatt deployed, and the cloud provider makes another $7 million to $10 million at today's pricing.

The speaker also argues that renting can work as a competitive lever. In the quoted example, if ByteDance wants to compete with Meta on video recommendation globally and is barred from buying chips but allowed to rent them, Meta potentially has a fourth of the cost of compute. A third quote says application companies running on open models add up to well over $10 billion in annual recurring revenue, that DeepSeek makes less than inference providers Baseten and Fireworks earn serving its models, and that America is making a great deal of money off Chinese models.

The opposite case drove the policy response. Lawmakers backing the Remote Access Security Act, and the officials behind the Commerce rule, argue that remote access lets Chinese labs train advanced models on US chips without importing them, which undermines export controls. The Wall Street Journal reported on November 14 that Southeast Asian data centers gave Chinese AI firms exactly that access. The figures in the clip are the speaker's estimates and were not independently verified.

What to expect next

Watch whether US cloud providers and Nvidia push for exemptions as the Commerce rule takes effect, using arguments like these. The rule already exempts commercial recommender systems, which touches the ByteDance example in the clip. The debate will also shape the final text of the Remote Access Security Act if Congress attaches it to the defense bill. Nvidia's results on November 17 may also show how much revenue comes from cloud customers in Southeast Asia.