Geoffrey Hinton on PBS: US AI Is Completely Unregulated, and US China Cooperation on Superintelligence Will Have to Wait Two Years
GODFATHER OF AI ON PBS LAST NIGHT: "HOW CAN I SAY THIS... MAYBE A CORRUPT SENILE FELON IN THE WHITE HOUSE." HE THINKS CHINA'S POLITBURO GETS THE AI RISK BETTER THAN THE US, AND THE TWO WON'T TEAM UP FOR 2 YEARS. On AI, Geoffrey Hinton is someone you can trust. He won the 2024 Nobel Prize in Physics for the research behind today's AI. Last summer he went to Shanghai and talked to one of Xi's protégés at the top of the Communist Party. His words on Firing Line: "I believe the Politburo understands this stuff much better than the U.S. government." Hinton wants Washington and Beijing to work together so superintelligence doesn't take over. Then he explained why that has to wait: "It won't happen while we still have a, how can I say this, maybe a corrupt senile felon in the White House. So it's not going to happen for two years." The host grinned. Do you agree with the Godfather of AI?
Context
One of the field's founders is telling a US audience that superintelligence may be only a few years away and that Washington is not acting, which feeds the regulation debate.
Geoffrey Hinton, the Nobel laureate often called the godfather of AI, appeared on the PBS program Firing Line with Margaret Hoover in an episode released November 13. A clip of the interview posted on November 14 by the account Sethian passed 200,000 views, and Elon Musk replied to it. PBS describes the episode as covering existential threats, Nvidia's Jensen Huang, cooperation between the US and China, and moral obligations to conscious machines.
Deep dive
The viral clip was posted by Sethian, a commentary account, at 5:12 AM ET on November 14. In the quotes the post attributes to Hinton, he says he believes the Politburo understands this much better than the US government, and that US and China cooperation on superintelligence won't happen while there is, in his words, maybe a corrupt senile felon in the White House, so not for two years. The capitalized framing at the top of the post is the poster's own; the full episode is on PBS.
In the PBS episode, Hinton says the United States has completely unregulated AI and that the federal government has suggested companies can regulate themselves, which he calls absurd. He says he once thought superintelligence was 10 to 20 years away, but that people inside the big companies are worried it could arrive within the next few years and that no one knows how to control it. He urges viewers to pressure politicians to take the threat seriously.
Asked about Jensen Huang, Hinton says he likes him, thinks he is a decent guy, and believes he made a mistake, adding that it was slightly stupid to think he would not be caught. He says he does not put Huang in the same category as Elon Musk or Mark Zuckerberg, whom he calls very self interested. On geopolitics, Hinton says that when it comes to superintelligence, the interests of China and the US are aligned and they will collaborate, comparing it to cooperation over the hydrogen bomb.
Elon Musk replied to the clip on the evening of November 14 ET with: "Hinton still thinks the news is real."
What to expect next
Watch whether Hinton's call for regulation gets any response in Washington, where the federal approach has favored letting companies set their own rules. Also watch for any formal US and China talks on AI risk, which Hinton predicts but which neither government has announced. His interview also touched on Anthropic and Dario Amodei, so watch for responses from lab leaders to his claim that insiders expect superintelligence within a few years.
