Joanna Stern's Review: Siri AI Improved This Year but Still Fails at the Basics on Apple's HomeView
Apple made big strides with Siri AI this year, but Siri still struggles with the basics. And nowhere is that more obvious than on the new HomeView. This clip from my review sums up the problem.
Context
The review, from a widely followed product critic, argues that Apple's new home device is being held back by Siri's failures on simple tasks, not by the hardware.
Joanna Stern posted a clip from her review on November 14, writing that Apple made big strides with Siri AI this year but that Siri still struggles with the basics, and that this is especially clear on the new HomeView. A written version of the review, published under her name at NBC News on November 13, presents the piece as a test of Apple's $299 HomeView and says the hardware is ready but Siri is not. Her New Things newsletter previewed the same review and said she spent a week testing the device with her family.
Deep dive
In the post, Stern said Apple made big strides with Siri AI this year, but that Siri still struggles with the basics, and that nowhere is that more obvious than on the new HomeView. She said the attached clip from her review sums up the problem. The post does not name the specific failures shown in the clip.
The NBC News writeup published under her byline on November 13 describes the HomeView as a $299 home hub and says she tested it with her family for a week. Its summary says the device knows who is who and can run the house, but that Siri got stuck on basic math. Her New Things newsletter, dated November 12, said Apple's impressive hardware is waiting for its software to catch up, and listed three promises she tested: family recognition, a command center for the house, and Siri AI as a personal assistant that actually makes life easier. She also wrote that she dressed up as the father in Apple's HomeView launch ad for the video review.
This is a review, not a company announcement. This scan did not find a Wall Street Journal page for the same review, so the written versions linked here are the NBC News article and her newsletter. Apple did not comment in the materials reviewed for this story.
What to expect next
Watch for software updates that address the basic Siri failures Stern describes, and for Apple's own comment on the HomeView reviews. Later hands on tests from other reviewers, or a follow up from Stern, would show whether the problems were limited to early software or persist after launch. Stern's newsletter and the NBC News version of the review are the best places to check for any follow up on Siri fixes.
